PurpleXVI posted:

I wonder if the badge is necessary to make this event happen?

That was a good thought. I was curious about this, so I tried it out from a earlier save.

It doesn't seem you need the police badge - but I did get absolutely destroyed from the first enemy I came across.

I suspect like Harper says, you probably go here earlier in the game and level up for the New York battle, since you can't do New York without the bullet proof vest, which you don't get until you finish that awful shooting minigame at the Grand Canyon.